Owing to the screen size of your device, you may obtain a better viewing experience by rotating your device a quarter-turn (to get the so-called "panorama" screen view).
This is …

That Useful Wine Site

Search, or just roll your cursor over the colored boxes farther below.
Advertisements appear before actual Search results;
click the "x" above to dismiss Search-results block.

  Advertisement:


  Site navigation:

  Advertisement:


  Site navigation:

The Pinot Noir Grape


Quick page jumps:


About Pinot Noir

(Synonyms: Auvernat, Auvernaut noir, Blauer-Klävner, Blauer Nürnberger, Blauer Spätburgunder, Burgunder blauer, Clävner, Franc Noirien, Franc Pineau, Möhrchen, Morillon, Nagyburgundi, Noirien, Pineau de Bourgoyne, Pinot nera, Plant Doré, Salvagnin, Schwarzer Burgunder, Schwarzer Riesling, Vert Doré.)

Background

Map showing Burgundy

Pinot Noir is a red-wine grape originating in the Burgandy region of France. It is generally considered one of the dozen and a half or so of world-class red-wine grapes (those in boldface in the varietals lists near the top of the page), arguably one of the top two (along with the Bordeaux type Cabernet Sauvignon).

Pinot Noir is a notoriously fickle grape in the vineyard. In its home, it has had many centuries of intense care, presumably leading to the use of clones that are exactly matched to their soils and microclimates; in other regions, that selection and adaptation is still a work in progress. There may well be more clones of Pinot Noir in vineyards than of any other wine grape.

(Clonal selection is a little-discussed but critical part of grape-growing and thus wine-making; there is a good discussion of Pinot Noir clones in this U.C. Davis report on the grape. Pinot Noir notoriously mutates quite readily, which is why its clonal variants differ from one another much more than is the case with most other wine grapes.)

The French passion for classification reaches its apex in Burgundy. In Burgundy, there are five growing areas, divided in total into fully one hundred AOCs (appellations d'origine contrôlée), and, within each, designations from "Grand cru" through "Premier Cru" and "Village" down to "Regional". (Take notes: there will be a quiz in the morning.) There is no point in re-inventing the wheel, and Hilarie Larson has a fine introduction to the world of Burgundy (including also Chardonnay) at the Wine Folly web site.

Some of the most fantastically expensive and swooned-over wines in the world are Burgundies of Pinot Noir. So what is this fascinating grape like? Well, once you have tasted it, you will not likely ever mistake anything else for it, or vice-versa (whereas, in contrast, there are several eminent Bordeaux reds that can readily be mistaken for one another). Jancis Robinson states that "Perhaps the only characteristics that the Pinot Noirs of the world could be said to share would be a certain sweet fruitiness and, in general, lower levels of tannins and pigments than the other 'great' red varieties, Cabernet Sauvignon and Syrah."

The great claim about Pinot Noir is that it is the premier grape for expressing that elusive quality, terroir. The French Wine Guide defines terroir as "a group of vineyards (or even vines) from the same region, belonging to a specific appellation, and sharing the same type of soil, weather conditions, grapes and wine-making savoir-faire, which contribute to give its specific personality to the wine." That's really not very helpful; as the Wikipedia article on the word better puts it, "Terroir can be very loosely translated as 'a sense of place', which is embodied in certain characteristic qualities, the sum of the effects that the local environment has had on the production of the product." That is why Pinots from vineyards scarcely a stone's throw apart (literally) can differ substantially in almost every respect (yet be equally good—or great, or mediocre—wines. Notice that neither definition refers to the wine maker: it is as if the wines magically make themselves from the grapes; obviously, however, the wine maker is, as one might say, the lens through which the the terroir is perceived in the glass.

(All this is only an extremely superficial introduction to the complexities with which Burgundy lovers must acquaint themselves; even just the Wikipedia article on Burgundy wines is a towering wall of text.)

If we try to get more definite, we can say that cruder Pinots, grown where the climate is really a bit too warm for it, produce relatively simplistic fruit bombs often described as "jammy"; we recall some that tasted like they should be spread on toast. In better circumstances, the resulting wine is light-to-medium in color and body, and pervaded by fruit flavors of the dark-red-berry sort, typically cherry but sometimes raspberry/strawberry. Beyond those basics come the highly variable terroir variations of earthiness, cedar, tobacco, and the usual host of vague words that try to express the subtle and complex red-wine flavors for which there are still really no good words.

Factoid: French wine law allows most Pinot Noir Burgundy to be cut with up to 15% of regional white-wine grapes. In practice, such blending is extremely rare.


Some Descriptions of Pinot Noir Wines


Some Pinot Noirs to Try

(About this list.)

As Jancis Robinson has remarked, "price is an extremely unreliable guide…what a wine sells for often has more to do with advertising hype and marketing decisions than the quality contained in the bottle." And that is so of Pinots from wherever it is made, not just Burgundy; this varietal seems to be more of a religion than perhaps any other.

When buying modestly priced real Burgundy, your chief clues to reliability are the négociant or the importer or both. Some highly reputed négociants are (in no special order) Louis Latour, Joseph Drouhin, Louis Jadot, Domaine Faiveley, Bouchard Père et Fils, and Olivier Laflaive; respected Burgundy importers include, among others, Kermit Lynch, Neal Rosenthal, Louis-Dressner, Robert Chadderdon, and Polaner Selections.

While top-rank Burgundies have prices that are the subject of jokes (and are actually treated as investments), remarkably decent Pinots can nevertheless be had for reasonable prices. Outside of Burgundy, the top Pinot regions would be Oregon and (perhaps especially) New Zealand, though we mustn't forget Austria; California Pinots (as some of the remarks above show) often are ill-made quasi-Cabernets (because that's what sells), but there are also some good specimens from select regions of the state. Nowadays, even South America is a region to notice for Pinots. We have tried here to present a palette of Pinot Noirs from a variety regions; as everyone says, there is no Universal Standard Pinot Noir under glass in a lab somewhere. The idea here is not to reveal all that Pinot Noir can be, but simply to get you started on a long road of exploration. Because Pinot Noir can be so many different things, our list here is longer than usual, and includes several wines from each of the four areas mentioned.

The quotations below are excerpts; we strenuously urge you to click on the green diamond symbol by each quoted review to see the full article.
De Bortoli "Reserve Release" Pinot Noir
(Yarra Valley, Australia.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

At first glance, the colour was much darker than the normal Pinot Noir. I really like the bouquet though. It was very expressive with layers of fruits and spice. However, the taste was too acidic for my liking initially. We decided to let the wine breathe in a decanter while we nibbled on the cheese and nuts. When we returned to the wine after half an hour, the palate was completely different. It was now soft on entry, with fine tannin and fresh acidity. A very fine and tasty wine that you would expect from Yarra Valley's finest. A truly deserved score of 93-points by James Halliday.

[P]erfumed and silky redcurrant and strawberry with asian spice and rose petal notes, the medium bodied palate builds intensity and savoury edged complexity along palate, multi-tiered lacy tannins with a tight acid backbone. (*****)

Like De Bortoli's Estate Grown Pinot Noir, this [2005] Reserve Release (also estate grown), is firmly built. Crisp acids and a big, burly mouthfeel accent sour cherry and cranberry fruit and an increased dose of new oak. It's plenty muscular, but could use a touch more finesse. 86 points.

It has a sweet dark cherry nose that’s quite forward and aromatic, with some earthiness in the background. The palate is smooth and elegant with dark fruits hiding a fair bit of structure. Very good/excellent. 93 points.

Medium red, not too dark in appearance. Aromas of red currant, cherry and raspberry with subtle spice and forest floor. Medium bodied but building in weight across the palate. Richly textured. Long and fine with gentle, palate defining tannins.

Pale cherry colour, pure and perfumed with wild strawberries and a sweet fruit attack which continues all through the palate. Light, elegant with full flavour intensity and length. Sweetness of fruit is the core of this, with a faint silhouette of supporting sandalwood under the horizon. Very good.



Stadlmann "Classic" Pinot Noir
(Niederosterreich, Austria.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

This wine's fresh, ripe red cherry and aromatic strawberry touches make for an inviting nose. The palate shows the same intense primary fruit, bolstered by freshness and a fine, filigreed structure. Its supple, pure fruit makes it very enjoyable now, but it's sure to evolve further with bottle age. 93 points.

The Stadlmann Pinot Noir ‘Classic’ 2005, from Thermenregion, south of Vienna, was a stunner. It started off with a concentrated, peppery strawberry nose, a hint of anise, a touch of licorice, and, unexpectedly, Mandarin-orange oil. On the palate, the silkiness of the texture stood out right away, a tactile creaminess that was balanced perfectly by the kind of acidity that you find in just-picked wild strawberries. This was complicated by cherry fruit, a hint of orange, sage, more high-toned spice, a wisp of bonfire smoke, and something seductively brambly. In other words, this is serious Pinot Noir, and a wildly successful argument for the virtues of Austrian Pinot. More people should make a point of learning about these Pinots in particular and Austrian wines in general: Their rewards are significant.

Translucent brickish red, the wine has great Pinot typicity, with aromas of rare meat and singed herbs. Lean and light-bodied with steely minerality that I associate with red Burgundy, but with an herbal top-note I associate with Austria. Lovely.

The scent of very ripe, crunchy Bing cherries is heady at first. On the palate, red cherry fruit dominates the soft, pliant and lighter body, fringed by pleasant earthiness. This is Pinot Noir in a very Central European idiom: Not weighed down with heavy oak but confident enough to let fruit and place speak for itself. This is elegant and soft, light-bodied yet ripe. If you listen to this, it will slowly reveal its undoubted beauty. 93 points, #20 of Top 100 for 2015.

Stadlmann also makes very noteworthy Pinot Noir. The wine spends time in large oak barrles for 12 months and has classic pinot noir aromas and flavors including soft berry notes and elegant tannins. I have had the occasion to try these wines in the years since that first meeting and they never disappoint.

http://www.burlingtonfreepress.com/picture-gallery/travel/experience/food-and-wine/2016/12/05/10-austrian-wines-to-try/94992250/?showmenu=true Light-bodied and elegant, the Stadlmann Pinot Noir Classic, 2013 brings lively notes of wild strawberry and violets to the palate. Soft, feminine and elegant…



Line 39 Pinot Noir
(Central Coast, U.S.A.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

A tasty vein of cranberry and raspberry runs from the nose to the palate, and lingers on the finish, giving this value-priced wine focus and vibrance. It has plenty of fresh acidity, fine tannins and good depth of flavor. 90 points & a Best Buy.

The 2012 Line 39 Pinot Noir begins with pleasant aromas of strawberry, raspberry, earth and a hint of rhubarb. This medium-bodied wine is really easy to drink and smooth with similar flavors to the nose plus a nice layer of spice. It’s a bit rustic (or maybe just rough around the edges), but that helps give the wine some nice character versus being artificially smooth. The medium-long finish is lightly spicy and strawberry notes linger pleasantly in the mouth. Proof you don’t have to spend a lot on your Pinot Noir to get the real thing! Taste Rating: 7; Cost Rating: 9; Overall Rating: 7.35. Recommended Buy

Bright medium dusty garnet color. Delicate, fruity aromas and flavors of baked cherries and honey roasted nuts with an even, crisp, fruity medium-to-full body and a tingling, rapid berry compote, blood orange, and roasted whole nuts finish with crunchy, dusty tannins and light oak. A rock solid pinot with nice fruit and structure.

Normally light to medium-bodied, pinot is known for its earthiness and delicate tannins. This California pinot — named after the 39th parallel that runs through the heart of wine country — is quite rustic. It’s the only time we’ve ever used an aerator on a pinot and the results were immediate — tannic and bitter notes changed to well-developed dark fruit and spice. Let this wine breathe and enjoy a fine pinot for under $10. Sherry: “Flavors of boysenberry, black cherry and spicy clove.” (3.25 stars out of 5) Chris: “A leathery bouquet with flavors of dark black cherry, cranberry and a spicy finish.” (3.25 stars out of 5)

The first thing you notice about [this wine] is its delicacy. It splashes over the palate with the lightest of touches and none of the brashness of youth. It's not a thin wine but it's not heavy, either. Tannins are long, smooth and supple, with a silken texture, a quality that makes this wine very food-friendly. Sweet spices, especially allspice, clove and star anise, weave through the wine, but with a light touch. Suggestions of black raspberry, Rainier cherries and red currants come to mind, though none dominates. The wine is beautifully integrated from its first sip to its teasing finish. Those who prefer ponderous pinot noir, the ones that have been over-extracted to attract the cabernet crowd, may dismiss this wine as wimpy, but anyone who appreciates the pretty, subtle spectrum for which the varietal is famous will embrace this wine enthusiastically. And at $11 it's a steal, among the finest inexpensive pinot noirs I've ever tasted.

At $11, this one is a great bargain, and while it's not the most delicate Pinot Noir on the market, it is a fun sipper with a lot of great balance…It opens up with a nose of ripe strawberry and earth, with a touch of pencil shavings. Mild and round with a little tannic bite on the finish. Full bodied for Pinot Noir, and one that will stand up well to heartier cuisine.



Errazuriz "Max Reserva" Pinot Noir
(Casablanca Valley, Chile.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

Plum and cherry aromas are the slightest bit stalky. In the mouth, this coastal Pinot is round and full in feel, with reedy cherry and plum flavors matched by creamy oak. Briny hints, vanilla and integrated oak help this Pinot finish with elegance. 89 points.

A suave red, with a silky mouthfeel and medium-grained tannins behind the flavors of cherry, plum and hazelnut. The spicy finish is long and rich, revealing accents of sandalwood. 90 points.[Wine Spectator]

Aromas of ripe strawberry and light stone follow through to medium to full body, silky tannins and a fresh, bright finish. 91 points. [James Suckling]

Deep red. Fresh red berries, cherry pit, candied rose and a hint of cocoa powder on the perfumed nose. Bright and energetic on the palate, offering juicy raspberry and bitter cherry flavors that deepen and turn sweeter with air. Smoothly plays richness off vivacity and finishes sappy and quite long, with fine-grained tannins lending gentle closing grip. 91 points. [Antinio Galloni, Vinous]

Max Reserva Pinot Noir is a higher level product from [Errazuriz] and is a beautiful wine. This is not a smash to the palate. Rather it is a delicate caress, a beautiful example of pinot noir. The tannins are fine, only apparent with the full gum swish. The palate delivers a lovely, bright wine with a smoky mineral finish. If you think about it, you’ll probably find some herbaceous notes like rosemary and thyme.

I love me some Errazuriz! A bit of a raspberry Snapple tea thing on the nose - tart red berries, tea, spice, whiff of earth and barnyard, and a hint of capsicum. Nice acidity on the palate with many of the same notes, especially red currants. Yum! 4/5



Dashwood Pinot Noir
(Marlborough, New Zealand.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

This is a nice, light colored pinot noir with intense aromatics. It's a little bit spicy on the nose with plenty of cherry and raspberry aromas complementing that spice. There's a hint of grilled meat and leather on the nose too. Soft cherry flavors make up the bulk of the palate, and while it's relatively simple it's also very enjoyable. There is a spice note that hits the mid palate and adds some interest. The acidity is nearly perfect. The finish brings a cranberry flavor, which dissapates quickly making for a relatively short finish. Nonetheless, I'm not disappointed in this wine. For the price, this is a very nice—and recommended—pinot noir.

Perplexing initial nose. Coconut! A piña colada tsunami—pineapple, coconut milk, strawberry garnish and a Meyer's Rum floater. It's all there, then 10 minutes later, it's gone. Just like that. Those initial few moments after a cork is pulled can be so touch and go—either very telling or completely irrelevant. But, whether I plan to let it breathe or jump right in, a little sniff and sip is never missed. The nose eventually settles on dark cherry, strawberry, green herb, and tomato. Soft spice, cocoa powder, musty and mushroom advance on the palate. My preferred New Zealand Pinot Noir for the price thus far.

The 2009 Dashwood Marlborough Pinot Noir begins with aromas of bright cherry and raspberry with a few herbal notes and a little spice. The wine tastes of juicy red and black cherry and has a nice layer of spice that carries all the way through to the finish. There's also some juicy fruit on the finish that lasts for quite awhile. This is a really nice, easy sipper and a great wine to pull out at your next party to introduce your friends to New Zealand Pinot Noir.

The aromatics are really attractive featuring red cherries, herbs, oak and a hint of cinnamon. The flavors echo the aromas. Juicy, light on its feet, with polished tannins and perky acidity on the somewhat lengthy finish. A very good daily drinker and an exceptional value.

This one has a fruity cherry, raspberry, herb, and spice character.

Surprisingly, 4 of those inexpensive wines made our top 10. Those four, the Waipara Springs, the Babich, the Dashwood and the Oyster Bay…represent excellent value in pinot noir, surpassing what just about any other region is offering.

Moderate reddish-purple hue in the glass. Fresh aromas of dried red fruits and herbs. Light and simple redder fruits are featured with cherry-red candy flavor prominent. Bright with gossamer tannins making for easy drinkability. Decent.

Another smartly priced wine, this one comes from the Awatere Valley. It displays the nervy, tight lines and purity so typical of Awatere pinots, together with a herbal twist that adds complexity.



Spindrift Cellars Pinot Noir
(Willamette Valley, U.S.A. This is their basic Pinot; they have several more upmarket Pinot bottlings.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

Unfiltered. Perfect marriage of crushed berries, herb garden, flowers and barnyard on the nose. Tart berries, including cranberries, on the palate with a touch of oak. Decent richness, smoothly textured and a pleasing citrus lift on the persistent finish. Plenty to like here.

This wine is not one of those super premium pinot noir thrillers which the Williamette Valley seems to produce with amazing regularity, nor is it priced as such. Instead, this is a very good single vineyard PN displaying the rich fruit and acidic balance of top quality pinots from this area. It is a light-boded wine but is chock full of flavors . .  Tantalizing aromas of dark cherry and black pepper leap immediately from the glass, but let this one breathe a bit and the layers keep opening. Flavors are lush and layerd with cherry & dark berry fruit most prominent, with prominent earth and a touch more black pepper on the finish. I'm a big fan of Oregon pinot noir and I try a lot of different ones at all different price points. Am always looking for wines that hit the "sweet spot" of quality-for-price. This one really hits the mark. Haven't found too many pinots this good for under $25.

♣ Wine Spectator (October 2010), 90.

Silky in texture, this dark, spicy red is fragrant with smoke, toast and mineral overtones as the cherry fruit character rolls nicely through the long finish. Outstanding: a wine of superior character and style.

This wine is the perfect mid-weight pinot with gobs of spice, fruit and bouquet. The taste sensations in this wine are really quite charming and seemingly go on forever. Those wishing for a powerhouse red for the season should not look for pinot noir in general or Spindrift in particular, because these wines offer elegance over mass and power. I think the Spindrift pinot is really quite something.

[F]ruit-forward Pinot Noir with bright strawberry, raspberry and cherry fruit. The flavor leads you into the well-managed, supple tannins. Overall balance is about perfect, and the finish leaves you wanting more (In my opinion). Well-made Oregon wine.It is balanced by fresh & lively acidity, very little wood and soft tannins make this wine very drinkable now and it should continue to cellar for years to come.

The Spinnaker Pinot Noir is excellent, with aromas of toasty oak with cherry and strawberry. It offers a soft even palate and a lingering finish with lively acidity.



Louis Latour "Domaine de Valmoissine" Pinot Noir
(France.)

• Retail offers of this wine listed by 1000 Corks
• Retail offers of this wine listed by Wine Searcher
• This wine's CellarTracker review pages.
• This wine's Wine Searcher "Tasting Notes" page.


Some quotations and facts about this wine:

[T]he color was more that of garnet – not ruby, as the vintner’s website states. On the nose we were delighted with the cherry and cherry pipe-tobacco. We anticipated the first taste of this well-heeled wine. Slightly tannic and light on the tongue, our first sip produced subtle notes of red currant, citrus, rum, and spices – namely cloves and mace. We loved it.

This Pinot Noir comes from a renowned Burgundy producer this time working outside of Burgundy. The area encompassed by Var includes the Bandol and Côtes de Provence regions, both of which have strict requirements that their red wines must include Mouvèdre and Grenache among others. As a Pinot, this falls outside of those requirements, and so must be designated IGP Var. This is an excellent introduction to European Pinot, at a very good price. Earthy and ripe with dried fruit and herbal tones and a classic structure, this is a wine for food…

Smells like Pinot, with meaty plum and fleshy black cherry aromas. Tastes like Pinot, with a supple texture and cola and black cherry flavors. Why can't more wineries turn out good Pinot at this price? 86 points.

Occasionally, a wine talks to you in an entirely different voice with it’s aroma than what you actually taste. This was the case with the Louis Latour Pinot Noir. A strong personality showed up in the aroma with floral stems, tobacco leaves, funky turnip greens, asparagus, cigar smoke and leather. The aroma kept evolving. There was a lot going on. I wondered if there might be a problem. However, the palate was entirely different than what I was expecting with soft tannins, red currents, black cherries, raspberries, spices and a lovely earthy floral accent. Overall, a very enjoyable Pinot Noir.

The wine, called Domaine de Valmoissine, is made with techniques that result in a soft, approachable style of wine that can be consumed within a year of harvest. The style of wine is called vin vermeil, which apparently was innovated by Latour at the end of the 18th century. I found the 2002 to be soft and lush with a spicy nose and that cherry fruit I look for in good pinot noir.

Though not a Burgundy, it is a good, well-priced…example of a French alternative that is lighter weight, less fruity, and more savory than a typical New World Pinot Noir.



For a Splurge

The range of possibilities is farcical. But the problems are these: first, anything that is within hailing distance of a plausible price (that is, to us, not over the middle to upper two-digit range) is little if any better than the wines listed above; second, and converse, anything that is non-trivially better than what's already on the list has a price at least way up the two-digit scale and often into (sometimes well into) the three-digit range. And recall that Jancis Robinson remark: "price is an extremely unreliable guide" to quality in Pinots. (One might also note that wine reviewers in Australia and New Zealand tend, as a class, to be much more generous with point scores than their confreres elsewhere, with 90 being almost the beginning of their scale; thus, wines from those regions will seem over-scored compared to those from other areas.)

All in all, though it may seem faint-hearted of us, we have opted to not specify any "splurge" Pinot Noir wines, considering it too risky a proposition. If you're in a mood to blow a wad on a special bottle of PN, consult a trusted local winemonger.


  Advertisement:


  

  Advertisement:


  



Disclaimers  |  Privacy Policy

owl logo This site is one of The Owlcroft Company family of web sites. Please click on the link (or the owl) to see a menu of our other diverse user-friendly, helpful sites. Pair Networks logo Like all our sites, this one is hosted at the highly regarded Pair Networks, whom we strongly recommend. We invite you to click on the Pair link or logo for more information on hosting by a first-class service.
(Note: All Owlcroft systems run on Ubuntu Linux and we heartily recommend it to everyone--click on the link for more information).

All content copyright © 2017 The Owlcroft Company
(excepting quoted material, which is believed to be Fair Use).

This web page is strictly compliant with the W3C (World Wide Web Consortium) Extensible HyperText Markup Language (XHTML) Protocol v1.0 (Transitional) and the W3C Cascading Style Sheets (CSS) Protocol v3 — because we care about interoperability. Click on the logos below to test us!



This page was last modified on Friday, 2 June 2017, at 5:16 pm Pacific Time.